AR-News: [US] When Murdering Animals Make Sense
news at upc-online.org
Fri Feb 13 16:40:29 EST 2004
United Poultry Concerns PO Box 150 Machipongo, VA 23405
Phone: 757-678-7875 Fax: 757-678-5070 www.UPC-online.org
February 13, 2004
When Murdering Animals Make Sense
By Karen Davis, PhD
For the past year, United Poultry Concerns and other animal advocacy
organizations have sought to have California veterinarian Gregg Cutler
removed from his position as poultry welfare representative on the animal
welfare committee of the American Veterinary Medical Association. Cutler
authorized the killing of thousands of unwanted battery-caged hens by
throwing them into wood-chipping machinery last February. This method of
killing chickens is not approved by the AVMA, who announced last April that
Wood Chippers [are] Not To Be Used for Euthanasia of Poultry.
If instead of wood chippers, Cutler had merely advised the Ward Egg Ranch to
use any of the standard AVMA-approved methods of killing the birds like
breaking and stretching their necks and/or asphyxiating them with carbon
dioxide inhumane methods notwithstanding their AVMA classification as
euthanasia (merciful death), this episode would not have been noticed.
Cutler claims in his defense that he was just acting as part of a
government-industry task force established to block the Exotic Newcastle
disease epidemic that threatened Californias poultry and egg industry last
year. The mass-extermination of over 3 million birds conducted by this team,
at a cost of more than $160 million including indemnities paid to
cockfighters, was not paid for by the industry but by U.S. taxpayers,
belying the idea that eggs and chicken are cheap.
Cutler was part of a team. The San Diego County Department of Animal
Services report showing that he authorized the wood-chipper killings
includes a document titled Southern California Biosecurity: Eliminating
A.I. [Avian Influenza]: Protecting Us All From the Next Bad News. This
document, a 9-page industry guide for dealing with avian influenza
outbreaks, includes a procedure for disposing of spent hens by throwing
them alive into wood chippers:
Compost or Cremate, on the farm, wherever possible. Most farms in Southern
California can do this. A few face neighbor or regulatory hurdles. When done
correctly this should be cheaper than sending birds to Valley Fresh [for
slaughter]; and much safer. You dont need to bring suspect equipment or
personnel onto your ranch at all.
Whole birds can be composted on site. We have Southern California farmers
who have done this with limited #s. You can ask for help.
Grinding birds first aids composting considerably. We have Southern
California farmers who have done this very successfully. You can ask for
A large chipper can be rented and set-up to discharge directly into a loader
bucket or other container.
Death is instant and humane.
The remains can then be dumped in a row on top of a generous bed of manure,
and covered with a deep mound of manure.
Bury the remains deep and away from the edges of the pile and you should not
have a problem with varmints.
The pile should heat up, and then start to cool. It should then be turned,
or churned, and allowed to heat up again. Continue the process until you
Some hay or other carbon source added in the chipping process is
The use of wood-chippers, in other words, is just business as usual,
sensible and efficient, a way of getting rid of some of the millions of
unwanted spent hens that the egg industry unloads each year, just as it
gets rid of its millions of unwanted male chicks by grinding them up alive
and/or suffocating them in trash cans at the hatchery.
As Ward Egg Ranch plant manager Ken Iryie told the San Diego County humane
officer last February, chipping chickens is so common that tree chipper
rental places even advertise in the poultry industry for that use. He said
his company was authorized to do this by veterinarians Dr. Cutler, Dr.
Kerr, and Dr. Breitmeyer [Richard E. Breitmeyer, California state
veterinarian] all of whom are with the Newcastle Disease Task Force. Iryie
said that the hens, who were placed in the tree chipper, were not infected
with Newcastle and that chipping chickens as a means of euthanization
had been authorized for the last three years. In industry terms the word
euthanize simply means kill, as when Cutler told DVM Newsmagazine: My
only regret is speaking as a scientist to county representatives and
consumer media who misconstrued my openmindedness for new alternatives to
euthanasia during a crisis" (January 2004).
Such crises are now taking place around the world from Delaware to
Indonesia. To protect the global animal food industry and save people from
the avian influenza epidemics brought on by humans, millions of chickens,
ducks, turkeys and other animals are being buried alive, gassed, drowned,
beaten to death, and burned to death, including actual old-fashioned ritual
holocausts of thousands of chickens by villagers in Bali, Indonesia. The
chickens are being set on fire to send off the evil spirits that they say
brought on the bird flu outbreak of thousands of chickens (AP, 2/11/04).
Although what is happening in other countries is being shown on American
television, we dont get to see the atrocities being conducted here at home.
Where were the TV crews last year when millions of birds in California,
Arizona, Texas and Nevada were being shot with pellet guns, beaten to death,
tied up in plastic bags, gassed with CO2, trashed and buried alive? Why didn
t we get a glimpse of the humane depopulation of the 86,000 birds so far
in Delaware? If our methods are so humane, why cant we watch them on
television and compare the ethical superiority of our own solutions to the
atrocities being conducted elsewhere?
Here, anyway, is an eyewitness account of one such episode that took place
in Maryland, in 1993, during an avian flu outbreak that according to The
Washington Post, 2/12/04, resulted in the destruction of tens of thousands
of birds, according to state officials.
On November 26 and 27, 1993, there was a holocaust on a game farm operated
by John L. Tuttle near Centreville, Maryland. Over 30,000 captive game birds
[pheasants, chukars, and quails raised and sold for hunting in Maryland and
surrounding states] were gassed, burned alive, clubbed, swung by the neck or
shot to death by a joint United States Department of Agriculture
(USDA-APHIS) Maryland Department of Agriculture task force. This operation
was supervised by Drs. Hortentia Harris and David Henzler of USDA-APHIS
[Animal & Plant Health Inspection Service] and Drs. Archibald Park and Henry
Virts of the Maryland Department of Agriculture.
Approximately half of the game birds (17,000) were housed in buildings.
The remaining birds were housed in outside flight pens. On Friday, November
26, large tank trucks brought in carbon dioxide gas (CO2) which was pumped
into the buildings which housed a variety of game bird species some of which
were suspected of harboring a pathogenic avian influenza virus. The plan was
to asphyxiate the birds with CO2 gas, then carry them to a trench in a front
end loader where they would be sprayed with an accelerant and burned.
Unfortunately, we learned that CO2 is not lethal. As soon as the unconscious
birds were exposed to fresh air they began to revive. Many of these birds
were burned alive. A fruitless attempt was made to asphyxiate the remaining
birds with exhaust gasses from an automobile. It did not work. Many more of
these birds were burned alive that day.
The remaining 17,000 birds, which were housed in outdoor flight pens, were
dispatched in a similar cruel and inhumane manner. Many birds were clubbed
until unconscious and then burned alive. Finally, over 500 rounds of shotgun
shells were used to wound, maim and kill the remaining game birds which
could not be captured. Many of these birds were burned alive. After the
carnage was over, this virus was determined to be non-pathogenic. The
depopulation was totally unnecessary (letter from a remorseful
participant to the Association of Veterinarians for Animal Rights, March
What if the depopulation had been deemed necessary? Would what was done to
the birds be okay, then?
An op-ed by philosopher Peter Singer and DawnWatch.com producer Karen Dawn
suggests that it could be (When Slaughter Makes Sense, Newsday, 2/8/04).
They defend the mass-extermination of animals to stem the spread of avian
flu and call public concern that the killings are purposeless misplaced.
According to the logic, we should kill all humans suspected of having, or
known to have, infectious diseases like flu and AIDS. Maybe if we had
exterminated suspected AIDS carriers at the beginning we could have stopped
the tide of AIDS.
Their argument for humane vegetarianism is psychologically undercut by their
first argument in which animals are represented as mattering so little that
the waste of their lives is compared to the waste of time forced on us
in airports going through scanners and being searched in case of hijackers.
The tone is patronizing towards the animals and towards the human emotions
that are suffering with these animals. They say of the exterminations that
[s]ince we are both actively involved with the animal-rights movement, most
people would expect us to think of them as atrocities. We are saddened, of
course, by the mass killings, but at least there is a valid purpose to them,
as they are designed to stop the spread of diseases that could cause many
How many animal advocates will commit to the idea that the cheap, crude,
cruel, pitiless methods that are being used to murder all these animals are
valid? Or to the implication that short of immediate worldwide
vegetarianism, nothing less drastic could be done?
It is painful enough to contemplate what the evolution of our species on
earth means for the rest of the living world, without the added sorrow of
seeing our animal victims be morally abandoned, subtly sacrificed and
derogated by their only defenders. By such unfeeling logic, the
wood-chipper solution makes perfect sense just as Gregg Cutler has been
saying all along. And if the wood-chipper killings got people to go
vegetarian, then what was done to those hens was balanced, and we could
assure the hens, if only we could, that their sacrifice was not in vain.
Karen Davis is the president of United Poultry Concerns, a nonprofit
organization that promotes the compassionate and respectful treatment of
domestic fowl. www.upc-online.org
More information about the AR-News