AR-News: Mad cow weighs down a $175 billion industry
wolfcrest at hotmail.com
Mon Jan 5 19:34:26 EST 2004
Mad cow weighs down a $175 billion industry
New slaughterhouse procedures, such as barring 'downer' cattle from the food
supply, aim to keep beef sales healthy.
By Brad Knickerbocker | Staff writer of The Christian Science Monitor
ASHLAND, ORE. The first weeks of the mad-cow scare in the US are rippling
out through the nation's economy.
In one way or another - from the tons of pet food made of "meat byproducts"
for nearly 140 million cats and dogs, to the $200 million in beef waiting
aboard ships and in port freezers, to meat-processing and trucking companies
sending workers home - the $175 billion industry affects many millions of
"Beef. It's What's for Dinner," proclaims the National Cattlemen's Beef
Association, and American eating habits bear that out. Some 78 million meals
featuring beef are served every day, according to industry and government
figures, and it's not just the pot roast or filet mignon. Beef extract made
from the remains of slaughtered cows is in taco fillings, pizza toppings,
and other popular foods as well.
Whether or not they're regular red-meat eaters, Americans are watching the
situation closely. While two-thirds still think the beef supply is safe,
according to a CNN-Time poll released over the weekend, a substantial 27
percent think otherwise, and they have either reduced their consumption of
beef or stopped eating it altogether.
Officials think they know - but still aren't absolutely certain - where the
Holstein slaughtered a month ago and later diagnosed with bovine spongiform
encephalopathy (BSE) came from, as well as how it contracted mad-cow
disease. Most of the 81 cows in the suspect herd have yet to be tracked
down. Livestock on a third farm in Washington State have now been
quarantined. US Department of Agriculture officials hope to be able to
account for the 20,000 pounds of recalled meat in the next few days.
But as new information on the case is revealed almost daily, it's unclear
what the long-term economic impact will be.
"The US beef export market lost to mad-cow disease won't come back anytime
soon," says Purdue University agricultural economist Philip Paarlberg. "We
are going to have to assure our trading partners that the beef supply is
safe, and that will take time."
"The mad-cow trade restrictions the United States imposed on Canada on May
20 remained rigid until Aug. 8, and even then the restrictions were only
partially eased," says Dr. Paarlberg. "In the world's view, it's a North
American beef market, not two separate countries."
The US Department of Agriculture (USDA) is moving quickly to address the
issue. Among the new rules for beef production: "Downer" cattle (those
injured or too sick to stand on their own) may not be used for human food;
slaughtered animals inspected for mad-cow disease may not be processed for
sale until test results are known; slaughterhouse techniques that can mix
brain or spinal-cord tissue with muscle meat must not be used. Eventually,
an electronic tracking system will allow quick determination of an animal's
origin and history.
In some ways, Uncle Sam is following the lead not only of critics, but also
of fast-food giants McDonald's, Wendy's, and Burger King, as well as several
of the largest livestock markets in the country. These businesses have
already restricted some potentially unsafe practices.
No longer slaughtering downed cattle is also likely to lead to better
treatment of animals in the first place. One possible change: not packing
them into trailers for 36 hours, which can cause broken legs.
"The ban will prevent enormous animal suffering by eliminating the cruel
practice of dragging downed cattle to slaughter," says Gene Bauston,
president of Farm Sanctuary, an organization in Watkins Glen, N.Y., that
provides shelter and lobbies for more humane treatment of farm animals.
"Removing downed animals from the human food chain will give farmers the
incentive to prevent the problem in the first place."
Unclear at this point is how many animals destined for the dinner table
actually will be inspected. Until now, only about 1 in every 25 downed cows
has been inspected for BSE and other diseases posing a threat to humans.
Cattle and meat producers are hoping for quick confirmation that the
diseased Holstein was shipped from Canada. That might allow the US to
declare that it is "provisionally free" of mad-cow disease under
But no matter what the outcome with this lone cow, beef industry practices
and government regulation have been changed forever - perhaps in ways yet to
"The USDA's response is a step in the right direction," says Andrew Knight,
a veterinarian in Seattle.
"However, the USDA's decision will not end the risks to American consumers,
not by a long way," says Dr. Knight. "Because cows affected by mad-cow
disease commonly take years to display any signs at all, let alone becoming
too sick to stand, and because the average American cow is slaughtered at
around 2 years of age, the majority of mad cows will continue to pass
undetected into the human food supply without a very thorough surveillance
"Places like Japan and Europe make even the new US standards look like a
joke," Knight adds. In Europe, 1 in 4 cows meant for human consumption is
tested; in Japan, all such cows are tested. Until now, just 1 in 1,700 cows
have been tested in the United States.
The love for all living creatures is the most noble attribute of man.
- Charles Darwin, The Descent of Man
Enjoy a special introductory offer for dial-up Internet access limited
time only! http://join.msn.com/?page=dept/dialup
More information about the AR-News