AR-News: (DC) Wolves are rebalancing yellowstone ecosystem

WeArPetitions at WeArPetitions at
Tue Oct 28 13:32:07 EST 2003

CORVALLIS, Ore. - The reintroduction of wolves into Yellowstone National Park 
may be the key to maintaining groves of cottonwood trees that were well on 
their way to localized extinction, and is working to rebalance a stream 
ecosystem in the park for the first time in seven decades, Oregon State University 
scientists say in two new studies. 
The data show a clear and remarkable linkage between the presence of wolves 
and the health of an entire streamside ecosystem, including two species of 
cottonwoods and the myriad of roles they play in erosion control, stream health, 
and nurturing diverse plant and animal life. 
The findings of these studies were recently published in Ecological 
Applications, a journal of the Ecological Society of America, and the journal Forest 
Ecology and Management. 
"In one portion of the elk's winter range along the Lamar River of 
Yellowstone National Park, we found that there were thousands of small cottonwood 
seedlings," said Robert Beschta, professor emeritus in the College of Forestry at 
OSU and an expert on streams and riparian systems. "There should also have been 
hundreds of young trees, but there were none. Long-term elk browsing had been 
preventing any seedlings from getting taller." 
That pattern was common throughout the study area - lots of seedlings in 
combination with large cottonwood trees generally more than 70 years old, but 
little or nothing in between. 
Young cottonwoods, willows, and other streamside woody species are a 
preferred food for browsing elk during the harsh winters in northern Yellowstone, when 
much of the other forage is buried under snow. But when packs of wolves 
historically roamed the area, food was not the only consideration for elk, which 
had to be very careful and apparently avoided browsing in high-risk areas with 
low visibility or escape barriers. 
Wolves were systematically killed in the Yellowstone region and many other 
areas of the West beginning in the late 1800s. A concentrated effort between 
1914 and 1926 finished the job - the last known wolf pack disappeared in 1926. 
"I considered a variety of potential reasons that might explain the 
historical decline of cottonwoods that began in the 1920s and have continued up to the 
last couple of years," said Beschta. "I looked at climate change, lack of 
floods, fire suppression, natural stand dynamics, and numbers of elk. But none of 
those factors really explained the problem. "Ultimately, it became clear that 
wolves were the answer." 
While elk populations fluctuated over the decades when wolves were absent, 
browsing behavior appears to represent an important factor related to streamside 
impacts. With no fear of wolves, the elk could graze anywhere they liked and 
for decades have been able to kill, by browsing, nearly all the young 
cottonwoods. Other streamside species such as willows and berry-producing shrubs also 
That in turn began to play havoc with an entire streamside ecosystem and 
associated wildlife, including birds, insects, fish and others. Trees and shrubs 
were lost that could have helped control stream erosion. Food webs broke down. 
"Before the wolves came back, it was pretty clear that in some areas we were 
heading towards an outright extinction of cottonwoods," Beschta said. 
Now, with the recent reintroduction of wolves back into Yellowstone in 1995, 
streamside shrubs and cottonwoods within the Lamar Valley are beginning to 
become more prevalent and taller, and were the focus of a second study in the 
same area. That study outlines how the fear of attack by wolves apparently 
prevents browsing elk from eating young cottonwood and willows in some streamside 
With the renewed presence of wolves, young cottonwoods and willows have been 
growing taller each year over the last four years on "high-risk" sites, where 
elk apparently feel vulnerable due to terrain or other conditions that might 
prevent escape. In contrast, on "low-risk" sites, they are still being browsed 
by elk and show little increase in height. 
"In one case where a gully formed an escape barrier for elk, the tree height 
went up proportionally as the gully deepened and formed an increasing barrier 
to escape," said William Ripple, a professor with the College of Forestry at 
OSU. "Where the fear factor of wolves is high, the young trees and willows are 
doing much better and growing taller." 
Traditionally, "keystone" predators such as wolves were known to influence 
the population of other animals that they preyed on directly, such as elk or 
antelope. What researchers are now coming to better understand is the "trophic 
effect," or cascade of changes that can take place in an ecosystem when an 
important part is removed, Ripple said. 
The comparatively pristine conditions of a national park allowed this type of 
research to make "cause and effect" studies more feasible, the scientists 
point out. 
"The removal of wolves for 70 years - and then their return - actually set 
the stage for a scientific experiment with fairly compelling results," Beschta 
In a larger context, the studies also raise valid questions about other 
complex and poorly understood interactions between plants, animals, and wildlife in 
disturbed ecosystems across much of the American West, and perhaps elsewhere 
in the world, the scientists say. In some areas of the West, the disappearance 
of up to 90 percent of the aspen trees has been documented - another species 
of plant that is also highly vulnerable to animal browsing when it is young. 
"The last period when aspen trees in Yellowstone escaped the effects of elk 
browsing to generate trees into the forest overstory was the 1920s," Ripple 
said, "which is also when wolves were removed from the park." 
But in at least one place - America's first national park - there is now 
cause for hope. While it is too early to confirm the widespread recovery of 
cottonwoods and willows, the reintroduction of wolves appears to have put a stop to 
major declines in the survival of these plants, the researchers found. 
"One point that should not be missed is this is actually great news for the 
potential recovery of cottonwood trees and mature willows in Yellowstone 
National Park," Ripple said. "We now have a pretty good idea why they were in 
decline and the return of wolves should help pave the way for their recovery. 
"Even though it may take a very long time, for a change it looks like we're 
headed in the right direction." 
By David Stauth, 541-737-0787


I am sometimes asked, 'Why do you spend so much of your time and money 
talking about kindness to animals when there is so much cruelty to men?' I answer, 
'I am working at the roots.'" ~ George T. Angell
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...

More information about the AR-News mailing list